Valve Blames Mastercard for Steam Adult Game Removals, Igniting Censorship Controversy

Valve has publicly accused payment giant Mastercard of pressuring Steam, through third-party payment processors, to remove certain game content deemed "offensive and lacking artistic merit." This move has drawn widespread attention within the gaming community, with many concerned that the incident could usher in an era of stricter commercial censorship.

Last month, Steam unexpectedly delisted numerous adult-oriented games, shocking the player community. Shortly after, another platform, Itch.io, followed suit, removing all NSFW (Not Safe/Suitable For Work) games. Anti-pornography group Collective Shout subsequently claimed success in lobbying payment processors to pressure these platforms, threatening to withdraw payment services otherwise.

Initially, Mastercard denied involvement in the decision, stating it "does not restrict any creative activities on platforms like Steam and Itch." However, Valve later clarified in an interview with Kotaku that payment processors relayed Mastercard's directives, demanding the removal of any content that could pose a risk to the brand's image, specifically citing Mastercard's "Rule 5.12.7."

That rule stipulates that merchants using Mastercard services must not submit any transactions "that may damage brand reputation," including "products and images that are clearly offensive and lack serious artistic value," even if such content is legally permissible.

Valve stated that while it has consistently adhered to only distributing legal content since 2018, its explanation was rejected by payment processors, precisely due to this vague "damage brand" standard. This rule effectively grants Mastercard and its partners broad subjective discretion to remove any content they "dislike."

Many commentators have pointed out that such a rule intertwines artistic value with commercial interests, establishing a highly subjective standard. For instance, Collective Shout previously singled out titles like "Grand Theft Auto V" and "Detroit: Become Human" as "lacking artistic value," despite their widespread critical acclaim within the industry.

It remains unclear whether payment institutions will relax their stance in the future, allowing delisted games to return to platforms. However, Itch.io has already begun relisting some free adult games and is actively working to restore more titles. This ongoing tug-of-war over content censorship, financial pressure, and creative freedom continues.


via: Kotaku TheGamer