'Project Hail Mary' Author Andy Weir Blasts Modern 'Star Trek' Shows: "The Rest of Them Can Eat Sh*t"

(Image: Paramount/Skydance)

With the sci-fi epic "Project Hail Mary" currently dominating the box office and earning rave reviews, original author Andy Weir has been making the promotional rounds. But beyond discussing his own work, Weir has some strong opinions on other sci-fi properties—and he didn't hold back during a recent appearance on "The Critical Drinker After Hours" podcast, calling many of the modern "Star Trek" series "sh*t."

During the conversation, host Will Jordan noted that the success of "Project Hail Mary" feels refreshing for audiences who grew up on "Star Trek" but find a lack of high-caliber sci-fi today.

Weir agreed, responding, "Yeah, I saw somebody say—and I forget who it was, I wish I could remember who said it, some analyst—he's like, 'All of modern science fiction is heavily influenced by 'Star Trek: The Original Series,' except for modern 'Star Trek.'' I'm Gen X, so the sci-fi I had was reruns of 'Star Trek: The Original Series' and 'Lost in Space.' There wasn't a whole lot of 'people having cool adventures in space' sci-fi until 'Star Trek: The Next Generation' came out."

(Image: Paramount/Skydance)

Weir then shared his candid thoughts on the current state of the "Star Trek" franchise and revealed he once pitched his own series to Paramount. "Okay, you're much harsher than I am. I'll give you my take, just as a viewer," Weir said. "I like 'Strange New Worlds,' I think it's pretty good. I don't hate 'Enterprise,' it was a little weird. And the animated one, 'Lower Decks,' is fun. The rest of them can eat sh*t. Also, one other thing: I pitched a 'Star Trek' show to Paramount. I had a Zoom meeting with the showrunners of all the 'Star Trek' shows and spent a lot of time talking with Alex Kurtzman, the executive producer. I don't like a lot of the new-gen 'Star Trek' shows. Alex is a great guy, but the shows are sh*t. He's a really nice guy, but they didn't go for my pitch, so you know, f--k 'em."

After Weir's comments went public, "Crime 101" author Don Winslow posted in defense of Kurtzman, calling him a visionary writer and showrunner. Winslow criticized Weir for denigrating another writer's work at the height of his own success simply because his pitch was rejected, suggesting Weir owed Kurtzman a professional apology.

(Image: Pinterest)

As the controversy grew, Weir issued a public apology earlier today in a statement on X. He addressed Kurtzman directly, writing that his comments were taken out of context and came across as a "vulgar, truncated message." He added, "I hope you also saw the parts where I said what a great and nice person you are. Also where I said I liked 'Strange New Worlds' and 'Lower Decks.'"

Weir explained that his "f--k 'em" line was meant as a self-deprecating joke that sounded serious when isolated. He acknowledged his blunt way of speaking and admitted he had forgotten to be more careful with his words now that he's back in the media spotlight. "In a few months I'll be back in my 'cave' writing novels and no one will care anymore," he concluded, offering to speak with Kurtzman directly.