HBO’s "Harry Potter" Great Hall Lamps Spark Backlash — Fans Say Hogwarts Has Lost Its Magic, but Oxford Uses the Same Design


HBO’s new "Harry Potter" series has yet to premiere, but a row of table lamps inside the Hogwarts Great Hall is already stirring controversy. The network recently unveiled a roughly 90-second clip from the start-of-term feast, showing students pounding on the tables and chanting, "Dumbledore," before headmaster Albus Dumbledore, played by John Lithgow, conjures a lavish spread with a snap of his fingers.


Yet the most eye-catching part of the scene was not the magic, but the glowing spherical lamps lining the long tables. Some viewers joked that the fixtures looked more like altar lamps, turning the set design into an unexpected talking point.

The series’ dim lighting, low-contrast color palette and production design have drawn complaints from some fans, who argued that the footage resembled a magic-free insurance commercial. Chris Columbus’ 2001 film used floating candles and warm tones to give Hogwarts its signature sense of wonder. By making the table lamps a prominent source of light, the series has raised questions about why the production altered such an iconic visual. The original novels famously describe thousands of candles floating above the Great Hall. Viewers shared their reactions online:

However, fans have pointed out that the table lamps may not be a baseless creative choice. On Reddit, a user who identified themselves as a University of Oxford alum compared the show’s Great Hall with dining halls at colleges including New College and Exeter College, noting similar lamps, flooring and spatial layouts.

The poster suggested that the production team may have drawn inspiration from those historic buildings in an effort to make Hogwarts look more like a traditional British college, though that remains fan speculation. Information about Exeter College’s lighting project also shows that its historic dining hall retained its table lamps and uses warm, dimmable bulbs to create an atmosphere reminiscent of candlelight.

Notably, the series has not removed the magical candles. The full clip shows them still floating above the students, but they are positioned much higher than in the films. As a result, the table lamps become the more prominent foreground light source, shifting the visual balance between the two.

via: The Independent