Ubisoft Argues Players Only Buy a 'License' to Games, Not Ownership, in 'The Crew' Shutdown Lawsuit

Ubisoft's decision to shut down the servers for its racing game "The Crew" has prompted a lawsuit from two players seeking damages and clarity on the issue of digital game ownership. In a firm legal response, Ubisoft has made its stance clear: "Players are not buying the game itself, but a 'limited license for access,'" a statement that has reignited the debate over digital property and consumer rights.

The controversy began with the 2014 release of "The Crew," whose servers were officially shut down at the end of March 2024. This move rendered the game completely inaccessible for all players, regardless of whether they owned a digital or physical copy. While its sequels, "The Crew 2" and "The Crew Motorfest," both offer offline modes, no such alternative was provided for the original title.

The plaintiffs in the case state that the game activation keys they purchased were marked as valid until 2099, creating a reasonable expectation for long-term playability. They accuse Ubisoft of violating California's False Advertising Law, Unfair Competition Law, and Consumers Legal Remedies Act, with additional allegations of fraud and breach of contract. They also reportedly used a "pinball machine" analogy to describe the feeling of having their right to use the product revoked.

However, in its response to the lawsuit, Ubisoft emphasized that players never held full ownership of the game. The company pointed to text on the packaging, printed in all caps, stating that Ubisoft could shut down certain online features with 30 days' prior notice, and that what players acquired was merely a license to use the software.

This case highlights the blurred line between "ownership" and "licensing" in the modern digital games market. Ubisoft has filed a motion to dismiss the lawsuit, but if it is not accepted, the case will proceed to a jury trial.

Digital platforms, including Steam, have already begun adding disclaimers to their game pages to inform users that they are purchasing a "license," not "ownership." This change was prompted by new regulations in California that require digital stores to clearly disclose the legal nature of the content they sell.

Yet, even with these advance notifications, the question of whether such a "license" is reasonable—especially when players find a game they paid for has become unplayable years later—will likely remain a major point of contention between gamers and publishers.

via: IGN