Nintendo's "Monster Capture" Patent Rejected by Japan Patent Office, Potentially Weakening Palworld Lawsuit Stance

A new development has emerged in the patent infringement lawsuit filed by Nintendo and The Pokémon Company against Pocketpair's game, "Palworld."

According to a report by "GamesFray," the Japan Patent Office (JPO) recently rejected a "monster capture" related patent application from Nintendo, citing a "lack of inventiveness." Analysts suggest that while this decision is not final, it could adversely affect Nintendo's position in the "Palworld" lawsuit.

The legal battle began in September 2024, when Nintendo and The Pokémon Company officially sued Pocketpair in Japan, alleging that "Palworld's" game system infringed upon three patents related to "monster capture and release" and "character riding." These patents were all approved by the JPO in 2024, with some extended from earlier applications in 2021, and were widely seen as "divisional patents" specifically designed by Nintendo to target "Palworld."

However, one of the patents submitted in 2024, numbered "2024-031879," has yet to be approved. In October, the JPO indicated that this patent "lacked an inventive step" and issued a non-final provisional rejection.

The patent examiner cited several older titles as precedents, including "Ark: Survival Evolved," "Monster Hunter 4," and the web game "Kantai Collection," noting that similar capture mechanisms already existed.

Ironically, "Craftopia," an older game by "Palworld" developer Pocketpair, and Nintendo's own "Pokémon GO," were also listed as examples lacking originality.

Although this rejection is not yet legally binding, its close association with two key patents currently invoked by Nintendo in the lawsuit (JP7505852 and JP7545191) could indirectly undermine the core foundation of the litigation.

Regarding this, IP consultant Florian Mueller stated: "The JPO's comparison to actual games, rather than solely relying on patent documents, makes Nintendo's position more challenging."

If the final ruling upholds the rejection, Pocketpair might be able to strengthen its defense, arguing that "Palworld's" monster capture mechanism is not plagiarism but rather a continuation and improvement of common design principles found in numerous games over the past decade.

Currently, the JPO has not issued a final judgment, but the industry generally believes that this rejection signals increasingly difficult challenges for Nintendo in the "Palworld" lawsuit.



via: GamesFray