Gamer Who Taunted Nintendo with "I Can Do This All Day" Hit with $17,500 Fine for Illegal Streams

A U.S. federal court in Colorado recently ruled against Jesse Keighin (online alias "Every Game Guru"), a player who had been illegally streaming Nintendo Switch games for an extended period, ordering him to pay Nintendo $17,500 in damages. The case garnered significant attention due to the defendant's repeated provocations against Nintendo, including claims like, "I have thousands of channels, I can do this all day."

According to court documents, Nintendo filed a lawsuit against Keighin in 2024, accusing him of illegally streaming at least 10 unreleased Nintendo games more than 50 times across multiple platforms since 2022. These streams involved leaked versions and unauthorized content. The latest title added to the infringement list was "Mario & Luigi: Brothership."

Nintendo's complaint highlighted that Keighin not only ignored warnings but also sent provocative letters to the company, boasting about having "thousands of backup accounts" to restart streams at any time. He also publicly mocked Nintendo's legal team on Facebook, stating, "You guys should do more homework."

Court records show that Nintendo filed another motion in April 2025, accusing the defendant of evading legal service. Notification was eventually completed via email and mail sent to his mother, grandmother, and partner's addresses. As the defendant failed to respond within the deadline, the court declared a "default judgment" on March 26, prompting Nintendo to request a direct default judgment.

Ultimately, the court ordered Keighin to pay $17,500 in damages, which included $10,000 for the infringement related to "Brothership" and $7,500 ($500 for each of 15 instances) as a penalty for repeatedly bypassing Nintendo's anti-piracy measures. The judgment noted that Nintendo could have sought a higher amount (up to $100,000) but chose to claim only for the most recent case, demonstrating a reasonable approach.

However, the court did not fully accept all of Nintendo's demands. Since Keighin primarily used publicly available emulator software for streaming, the judge deemed a permanent injunction "requiring the destruction of all infringing devices" to be too vague and unreasonable, thus rejecting it. Similarly, Nintendo's request to "prohibit any acts of assisting third parties" was also denied for failing to specify the targets.

In a statement, Nintendo affirmed that this case once again underscores the company's determination to protect its intellectual property and serves as a warning to individuals and platforms attempting to stream its games through piracy or emulators that any copyright infringement will face legal consequences.


via: TorrentFreak