John A. Squires, Director of the United States Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO), has ordered a re-examination of Nintendo's controversial "summoning characters to battle" patent, drawing significant attention from the gaming and legal communities.

Since its grant, the patent has faced criticism for being overly broad and seemingly encompassing core mechanics of the 'Pokémon' series. The official decision to re-examine it could severely undermine Nintendo's legal basis against 'Palworld'.
In his order, Squires noted two older patents that could serve as prior art references: one filed by Konami in 2002 and another by Nintendo itself in 2019. He stated that these documents "are critical to determining whether the patent is valid" and explicitly pointed out "a substantial new question of patentability."
According to 'Games Fray', the decision partly stems from "strong public backlash against the abuse of the patent system." While not an official revocation order, the industry widely expects the patent to ultimately be withdrawn. Nintendo currently has two months to respond.
This move significantly impacts the legal actions taken by Nintendo and The Pokémon Company against Pocketpair, the developer of 'Palworld'. Mueller noted that this re-examination "further weakens Nintendo's credibility in the lawsuit."

In fact, Nintendo recently faced a setback in Japan as well, where its "monster capture" related patent, filed last year, was rejected by the Japan Patent Office due to a lack of inventiveness. The JPO cited several earlier games, including 'Ark: Survival Evolved' and 'Monster Hunter 4', as precedents.
Since last year, Pocketpair has repeatedly modified 'Palworld's game mechanics to avoid controversy, including removing the mechanic of throwing spherical items to summon Pals, opting instead for them to appear directly next to the player. The patent battle continues to escalate, with Nintendo even amending its patent claims mid-lawsuit, arguing that mods should not be considered "prior art."
The lawsuit is currently being heard by Judge Motoyuki Nakajima at the Tokyo District Court, with a result expected next year. Mueller assessed that "the likelihood of Nintendo losing is steadily increasing."
This battle, hailed as "the most significant patent dispute in the gaming industry," not only concerns the future of 'Palworld' but also the redefinition of "the boundaries of creativity and mechanics" across the entire gaming sector.
via: Games Fray
