Manga Editor Spills the Tea: Publishers Once Rejected Artists Under 25! Fans Clap Back with a List of Teen Prodigies

A recent bombshell dropped on X (formerly Twitter) in Japan, as a manga editor revealed a wild, outdated rule from the industry's past, sparking a massive online debate.

Manga editor Toru Ishii (@tonyishiieditor) posted about some publishers' old policy of only accepting submissions from new artists "aged 25 or older," igniting a firestorm with his claim that "there are almost no successful manga artists who debuted at a young age."

In his post, Ishii explained that his former editorial department believed people needed to be around 25 for their self and emotions to mature, allowing them to truly understand others' feelings and societal realities. Their rationale? "I've barely heard of any manga artists who debuted in their teens and found success. As far as I know, Makoto Kobayashi might be the only exception." He stressed, "Before 25, the self isn't fully formed, making it hard for works to deeply resonate with others."

But here's the kicker: Ishii also spilled the beans about a manga artist who once submitted to "Weekly Shonen Magazine," claiming to be 26 when they were actually 36. They ended up getting serialized! "This proves that age is irrelevant; success hinges purely on sensibility and imagination. Restricting submission ages is utterly foolish."

Once this archaic editorial rule came to light, manga fans and netizens erupted in fierce backlash, arguing that age has zero direct correlation with creativity. They pointed out countless manga artists who debuted young and showcased incredible talent.

One netizen even compiled a list of "genius" mangaka to debunk the "maturity" theory: "Yu Yabuuchi of 'Mizuiro Jidai' (13 years old), Aya Ikue of 'Bara-iro no Ashita' (14), Shotaro Ishinomori (16), Takeshi Obata (17), Ai Yazawa (18), Yukari Ichijo (18)... So many debuted and found success before turning 20. You can't call them exceptions!"

Other users piled on with more examples: Osamu Tezuka (debuted at 17), Leiji Matsumoto (15), Rumiko Takahashi (21), Eiichiro Oda (24), Hirohiko Araki (20), and many more. These titans of manga almost all broke out before 25. Seriously, who thought age was a valid metric for artistic potential?

Some netizens also highlighted a contrasting trend: "In the shojo manga world, early bloomers are the norm. Winning awards and getting serialized in your teens is commonplace. Debuting at 25? That's practically ancient history!"

Manga artist Gaku Miyao also chimed in on X: "Turning 25 doesn't magically make everyone mature. Plenty of 30 and 40-year-olds are still acting like kids. Conversely, some teenagers can build entire, intricate worlds. Judging creative potential by age is just too crude."

Netizens further elaborated that from the Showa to early Heisei eras, the shojo manga industry actually had a prevailing sentiment: "If you haven't debuted by 25, it's too late." Many legendary creators like Machiko Satonaka, Suzue Miuchi, Keiko Takemiya, and Riyoko Ikeda almost all submitted or won awards in their teens. "Back then, the dominant themes were school-life manga, and authors who were still students themselves could capture the most authentic school atmosphere."

This whole "25-year-old theory" debate likely stems from Toru Ishii's past tenure within the Kodansha system, suggesting it might have been an old internal rule there. However, it's clear that countless manga artists have burst onto the scene in their youth, even their teens. The true key for a mangaka isn't age, but keen observation and boundless imagination. From teenage prodigies to late bloomers, diverse backgrounds forge different depths of creativity. While it's hard to imagine any publisher enforcing such a narrow-minded restriction today, the fact that it *was* a thing in the past truly shows how limited some perspectives once were.

via: togetter