Ever had a friend ask for manga recommendations? You usually consider their tastes and interests, or maybe you just push your personal faves on them.
Recently, a Japanese X (formerly Twitter) user shared a hilarious anecdote: A classmate they weren't particularly close with suddenly approached them, asking, "Hey, you're a manga otaku, right? Got any manga that feels 'sparkly' when you read it? I've been feeling a bit down lately and want something bright and shiny." The user, without missing a beat, pulled out Land of the Lustrous—a series renowned for its exquisite gem characters—and recommended it. Naturally, this move went viral on X, with netizens absolutely roasting them.

While the original poster claimed it perfectly fit the "sparkly" concept and even generously lent the entire series, anyone familiar with Land of the Lustrous knows it's absolutely NOT a feel-good, healing story. Reading it will only send your mood spiraling further down the drain, trust us.

Once the post blew up, comments poured in, a mix of laughter and outrage: "They said they were feeling low, and you lent them Land of the Lustrous? Do you even have a heart?!"

The replies were instantly flooded with wry remarks: "You're not lending manga; you're declaring war." "Sure, Land of the Lustrous is sparkly... but the sheer impact of its content will make you 'enlightened' in the worst way." "Plenty of battle scenes, but 'humans' never die—well, 'humans' anyway." "True hell mode would be pulling the last volume and only lending up to volume 12, leaving them half-dead."

The original poster's twisted logic even inspired a wave of netizens to start recommending their own "depressing manga" reading lists:
One user suggested that if you *really* want "sparkly," you could also recommend titles like Bokurano: Ours—works that are "cute on the outside, blades on the inside"—to truly twist the knife.

Another recommended School-Live!, with its school theme and adorable girls on the cover. Surely that'll make anyone feel sparkly, right? XD

Someone else threw in Happy Sugar Life—such cute girls, and it seems like a yuri theme, so it must be sweet and healing (?).

And of course, no such list would be complete without Made in Abyss—a true healing masterpiece, obviously www.

What started as a simple manga recommendation unexpectedly spiraled into a massive trend of "depressing manga reading list" sharing. Guess it's always safer to check your friend's mental fortitude before trying to "comfort" them with a manga recommendation! XD
via: togetter