"Want Japanese Anime/Manga Without Japanese Settings"? This "Internationalization" Debate Has Japanese Netizens Fuming: "Make Your Own!"

A hot debate has been brewing on Japanese X (formerly Twitter) recently: the idea that "I want to watch Japanese manga and anime, but I don't want them set in Japan." Some users are pushing for more "internationalization," sparking heated discussions and drawing strong rebuttals from Japanese netizens.

The discussion was ignited by this user's post:

"Honestly, I might get flamed for this, but I'm genuinely curious: why is everyone so obsessed with the latest Japanese manga, anime, and light novels? I get that Japanese works definitely have a universal, appealing charm. But don't your own countries have plenty of great content written in your own languages?"

"Every country has manga artists, novelists, and produces anime, movies, and TV series. Surely, many of those works are super interesting, right? Instead of constantly looking outwards, wouldn't it be more helpful for local creators if you supported and enjoyed your own domestic works first? Is that a weird thought?"

This post caught the attention of another user, Orita, who highlighted a recurring sentiment from overseas audiences, often surfacing due to issues like piracy:

"I really want to read Japanese manga, anime, and light novels, but I don't like the Japanese settings. I wish they were more international."

Japanese response: "But these are originally written by Japanese authors for Japanese readers."

"It's weird for Japanese creators not to target the international market!"

Japanese response: "Actually, the domestic Japanese market is enough, and even Japan-centric works sell incredibly well worldwide."

"Japanese people just don't understand business!"

Japanese response: "Ultimately, if you want to see your own country's settings, why not foster creators in your own country, or even try writing something yourself? That's how Japanese creators developed."

"Japanese people are just racist!"

Orita commented that these back-and-forth exchanges often feel less like a discussion and more like some people are trapped in their own echo chambers, making genuine communication impossible.

Many opinions highlight that creators naturally choose cultural backgrounds they're familiar with. Most people have limited understanding of foreign cultures, and the cost of research and verification is high. Inaccurate portrayals can easily draw criticism. Therefore, setting works in one's own country is not only logical but also ensures quality. It's baffling why some overseas netizens demand "internationalization" by wanting "Japanese works without Japanese settings."

The discussion also brought out some hilarious jabs, like, "Why are all the 'isekai' portals in Japan?" — a nod to how countless current Japanese fantasy works seem to have their otherworldly gateways exclusively located in Japan.

To the chorus of "we want more non-Japanese settings," most netizens offered a consistent reply: "Then cultivate creators in your own country, or just create it yourself!" Some even bluntly stated that creation inherently stems from "not seeing the works you want," so instead of demanding others change, it's better to make it happen yourself.

Some more neutral voices acknowledged that differing opinions are natural as the market expands. However, many overseas fans were drawn to Japanese works precisely because of their unique cultural backgrounds. Over-pursuing "globalization" might actually dilute the original charm of these works.

Most Japanese netizens believe that instead of demanding Japanese works change direction, it's better to foster local creative talent from one's own culture. Asking others to "internationalize" seems to fundamentally miss the point.

via: togetter X帳戶 おりた