Japan's National Diet Library Rejects Switch 2 Game Key Cards, Only Full Physical Cartridges Qualify for Preservation

Ever since the Nintendo Switch 2 hit the scene, it's been making waves—not just for its specs and game lineup, but also for its controversial "Game-Key Cards." Now, Japan's National Diet Library (NDL) has officially weighed in, declaring these data-less cards ineligible for preservation, fanning the flames of debate even further.

The Switch 2 offers two physical formats: the traditional, full game cartridge you can just pop in and play, and the "Game-Key Card." While these key cards still need to be inserted into the console to launch a game, they don't actually contain any game data themselves—players still have to download the content online. Sure, they're not just a "download code in a box" and can at least be resold, but many gamers are still ripping into them for stripping away the essence of physical collecting and preservation.

Game preservation is precisely at the heart of this whole kerfuffle. Many players are worried that if servers ever shut down or internet access becomes restricted, these key cards will become nothing more than unplayable "empty shells." And now, the NDL's latest statement seems to be siding squarely with the opposition.

As Japan's largest and only "legal deposit library," the NDL has been tasked with preserving domestically published video games since 2000, requiring publishers to submit copies of their works. With the Switch 2's release, preservation efforts are underway, but the scope is strictly limited to "physical media that actually contains game content."

In other words, full cartridges like "Mario Kart World" will be preserved, but key card games such as "Disgaea 7 Complete" won't make the cut for the preservation list.

It's worth noting that the NDL has already started preserving digital books and magazines in recent years, signaling an expanding digital archiving strategy. This has led to speculation that games might eventually be included in their digital preservation efforts. However, under current regulations, key cards are still locked out of Japan's national preservation system.

For gamers, this decision undeniably shines a spotlight on the key cards' shortcomings once again. While they might be tradable, they lack both preservation value and any guarantee of long-term playability. As the controversy heats up, striking a balance between publisher convenience and player preservation needs will remain an ongoing challenge for the Switch 2 ecosystem.


via: ファミ通.com