Japanese Lawyer's Call for "International Standards" in Anime/Manga Sparks Outrage, Even Elon Musk Chimes In: "Disgraceful!"

A prominent Japanese lawyer recently ignited a firestorm on social media with his assertion that "anime and manga should be produced according to international standards." The comments sparked a furious backlash from anime and manga fans both in Japan and abroad. The controversy quickly escalated on X, even drawing a personal response from Tesla CEO Elon Musk, who slammed the lawyer as "shameless" and questioned, "Who paid him to push this narrative?"

The controversy began when well-known Japanese lawyer Masahiro Kitoh offered his opinion on a dispute involving YOSHIKI of X JAPAN and the anime "Dandadan." In his statement, Kitoh remarked, "In my personal opinion, I believe this matter may infringe upon certain domestic and international rights of YOSHIKI." He then added, "We should pause and reconsider producing manga according to international standards. This is a necessary condition for Japanese manga and anime to truly globalize."

These remarks immediately drew sharp criticism from creators and anime fans, who decried them as "cultural suicide." Many argued that despite his fame, Kitoh appeared completely clueless about anime, failing to grasp the fundamental context of the issue. They accused him of merely trying to flaunt his expertise by advocating for "international standards," potentially jeopardizing Japan's most powerful soft power.

Even overseas netizens joined the fray, asserting that Japan has absolutely no need to conform to any "international standards." They emphasized that fans are drawn to Japanese creations precisely because of Japan's unique culture, urging the lawyer not to misunderstand what makes Japanese content beloved worldwide.

The incident gained further traction when former Japanese politician Yoshiyuki Kurishita posted about it in English, writing:

"Yesterday in Japan, a well-known lawyer's statement that 'anime and manga should conform to international standards' ignited a massive debate. I'm incredibly grateful for the overwhelming responses, such as 'overseas fans don't want that at all' and 'this will only destroy the culture.' These voices reached Japanese creators and fans, fueling an increasingly intense discussion that eventually became a major trending topic on X in Japan.

I believe this issue wouldn't have blown up to this extent without the support of our overseas friends. At the same time, it has made many Japanese people, who previously hadn't paid much attention to such problems, realize the terrifying implications of so-called 'international standards.' Moving forward, I will continue to work with friends around the world to protect content culture like anime, manga, and games."

This post, in turn, caught the attention of Elon Musk, who personally responded: "That lawyer is a disgrace. Who paid him to push this narrative?" Musk's comment instantly sparked heated discussion.

Many netizens expressed gratitude for Musk's statement, viewing it as strong support for the Japanese content industry. Comments included: "Musk truly understands the value of manga," and "Thank him for standing with creators." Others pointed out that "international standards" are often a guise for "Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI)," which in practice leads to censorship and restricts creative freedom.

This incident has also made more Japanese creators and readers realize that blindly pursuing so-called international norms could lead to the loss of the unique cultural charm that defines manga and anime.

If Japanese works were to truly conform to these "international standards," they might no longer be the authentic products of Japanese culture.


via: togetter