"Too Old to Read"? Recommending Togashi's "Level E" Sparks Generational Debate Online!

Hey internet, what do you consider when recommending manga or anime to your friends? Beyond just the genre or style, do you ever think about how a work's age might influence how different generations perceive it?

Recently, a Japanese netizen's post ignited a cross-generational discussion online. They shared how they recommended Yoshihiro Togashi's classic manga, "Level E," to a younger friend, only to be met with the response: "It feels too old overall, I can't get into it." This generational gap left many netizens scratching their heads, wondering if it's truly about the work's age or a genuine divide in taste.

The original poster, "Destro," self-deprecatingly admitted that they used to think complaints about "old otaku" were exaggerated. But after experiencing it firsthand, they finally understood the shock. They recommended "Level E" to a junior, only to receive a reply the next day: "I bought it, but it feels too old, I can't read it." This left Destro heartbroken, exclaiming dramatically that they "felt like they just vanished from the street."

This post quickly grabbed attention, with many netizens puzzled by the "too old to read" comment. Was it the art style? Or were the jokes and references too dated to understand? Many felt that good works should transcend time. Of course, "overall too old" could indeed be due to outdated pop culture or current events references that just don't land with a younger audience.

Some netizens chimed in, acknowledging the difficulty of the issue. They admitted that black-and-white films (outside of Kurosawa) and the first part of "JoJo's Bizarre Adventure" felt like high hurdles to them. However, after discovering newer works that paid homage to these classics, they suddenly understood: "These classics truly never fade."

While "Level E" is indeed a work by Yoshihiro Togashi, even coming after "Yu Yu Hakusho," it was a short series with only three tankobon volumes. Its anime adaptation also dates back to 2011. For many, it's a classic, but its fame doesn't seem to have carried through the generations quite like "Yu Yu Hakusho."

Many netizens pointed out that "Level E"'s "gekiga" art style at the time could indeed feel old-fashioned. Whether someone can get into a manga often boils down to the art. They recalled reading Osamu Tezuka's manga back in the day, suggesting that perhaps kids today finding "Level E" "old" might just be a matter of personal taste.

Netizens advised that when recommending works, one should consider the other person's preferences, as well as the work's age, length, completion status, or even its entry barrier. This helps avoid scaring off younger readers right from the start. Some offered "Yu Yu Hakusho" as a counter-example, noting that despite being older, it's still loved by young people today, proving that "personal taste" is often more crucial than a work's age.

In fact, some even confessed to almost dropping "Demon Slayer" after its first chapter because the art style felt "like a Showa-era manga." This shows that "age" isn't always about the release date. Others recalled recommending "Phoenix" (Hi no Tori), which, despite its age, was well-received, demonstrating that "classic status" and "entry barrier" aren't necessarily at odds.

That single phrase, "too old to read," has sparked a generational battle! For anime and manga fans, encountering similar situations might make them think twice when recommending works – it's truly an art form in itself.

Is it that the work itself fails to resonate with the new generation, or is it simply a mismatch of personal taste? Perhaps it truly varies from person to person.

via: togetter