
While the video game industry has long chased hyper-realistic graphics and physics simulations, Nintendo's legendary game designer Shigeru Miyamoto offered a radically different take a whopping 40 years ago. In a 1989 interview with the Japanese publication "Gamer Handbook," Miyamoto argued that games overly focused on realism often missed the point of fun, even boldly stating that many visually stunning titles of the era were "actually failures."

Miyamoto pointed out that some games at the time prioritized animation fluidity and visual flair at the expense of responsive controls and overall gameplay. He elaborated:
"Players often get frustrated with games that have lots of animation but sluggish controls." Miyamoto cited the popular "karate games" of the period as an example, noting that while their movements looked incredibly polished, their gameplay fell short: "The actions in those titles were certainly beautiful, but as games, they were almost failures."
For Miyamoto, the essence of a game isn't mimicking reality, but rather delivering excellent control and sparking imagination. He highlighted how Mario's abilities in the "Super Mario" series are far from realistic, yet it's precisely these exaggerated mechanics that make the game so enjoyable.
"If you think about it, Mario's jumping ability is incredibly exaggerated... he could probably be the greatest Olympic athlete ever," Miyamoto chuckled. "But if he could only jump like a normal person, then adhering to real-world physics would be fine."

He also reflected on the design evolution from early "Donkey Kong" to "Mario Bros.," noting that as character jump heights and actions became increasingly unrealistic, the game worlds began to develop their own non-realistic daily routines: "The fun part of games is creating a world that looks real but doesn't actually exist."
When discussing his creative inspirations, Miyamoto revealed that Nintendo's early designs were heavily influenced by classic comedies and animations, including Charlie Chaplin films and "Tom and Jerry."
"Cartoons from that era, like 'Tom and Jerry,' essentially took realistic rules and exaggerated them," Miyamoto explained. "So works like Chaplin's and 'Tom and Jerry' have always been crucial fuel for our creations."

Furthermore, he criticized some games in the interview for relying too heavily on hidden content and secret designs. Miyamoto stated: "I feel like the world of 'hidden secrets' in games has almost evolved to a bizarre degree, like pornography." This comment also reflects his deeper thoughts on the direction of game design.
via: GamesRadar+